*We emphasize the fact that awards are not given solely on points, but voter opinions, meaningful-game analysis, & individual review.
| First Team – East | 2024-2025 | ||
| Player | Yr. | Team | Pos. |
| Erika Goleniak | Sr. | Elmira | F |
| Mackenzie Hull | Sr. | Oswego State | F |
| Anna Dale | So. | Lebanon Valley | F |
| Gretchen Dann | Jr. | Amherst | D |
| Mattie Norton | Sr. | SUNY Plattsburgh | D |
| Natalie Stott | Jr. | Amherst | G |
| Second Team – East | 2024-2025 | ||
| Player | Yr. | Team | Pos. |
| McKenzie Schmidt | Sr. | Elmira | F |
| Haylee Bouchard | So. | Wilkes | F |
| Teaghan Hall | Jr. | Endicott | F |
| Sabrina Kim | Sr. | Middlebury | D |
| Kayla Persinger | Jr. | SUNY Cortland | D |
| Lexi Levy | Sr. | Oswego State | G |
