*We emphasize the fact that awards are not given solely on points, but voter opinions, meaningful-game analysis, & individual review.
| First Team – West | 2024-2025 | ||
| Player | Yr. | Team | Pos. |
| Logan Dombrowsky | So. | St. Norbert | F |
| Hassan Akl | Jr. | Aurora | F |
| Landry Schmuck | Fr. | Aurora | F |
| Juliano Santalucia | Jr. | Aurora | D |
| Connor Kalthoff | Sr. | St. Olaf | D |
| Hunter Garvey | So. | St. Norbert | G |
| Second Team – West | 2024-2025 | ||
| Player | Yr. | Team | Pos. |
| Fletcher Anderson | Sr. | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | F |
| Liam Fraser | Sr. | St. Norbert | F |
| Ian Amsbaugh | So. | Adrian | F |
| Noah Pickart | Jr. | Marian | D |
| Wyatt Wurst | Fr. | St. Scholastica | D |
| Alex Proctor | Jr. | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | G |
