| Saturday – March 22, 2025 | League/Event | Start Time | Result | ||
| #11 Nazareth (21-6-1) | @ | #3 Middlebury (20-6-1) | Winner plays Amherst/Colby | 3pm ET (Stream Link) | #3 Middlebury 1-0 |
| #8 Colby (18-6-2) | @ | #2 Amherst (21-5-1) | Winner plays Middlebury/Nazareth | 3pm ET (Stream Link) | #2 Amherst 4-1 |
| #9 St. Norbert (25-4-1) | @ | #1 Augsburg (23-3-1) | Winner plays Elmira/UWRF | 3pm CT (Stream Link) | #1 Augsburg 4-2 |
| #12 Elmira (21-7-1) | @ | #4 UW-River Falls (23-3-2) | Winner plays Augsburg/SNC | 3pm CT (Stream Link) | #4 UWRF 4-1 |
